• ! ! ! IMPORTANT MESSAGE ! ! !

    Discussions about police investigations

    In light of recent developments about a player from Premier League being arrested and until there is an official announcement, ALL users should refrain from discussing or speculating about situations around personal off-pitch matters related to any Arsenal player. This is to protect you and the forum.

    Users who disregard this reminder will be issued warnings and their posts will get deleted from public.

Arsenal Vs Newcastle ( Part 2 ) : Player Ratings

Nyingmeh

Active Member
Almunia -- 7 ( Was present )
Clichy -- 7 ( as usual )
Senderous -- 7 ( one of his best games recently )
Gallas -- 7 ( Captain fantastic )
Sagna -- 7 ( nothing to add )
Flamini -- 8.5 ( what a beast , omni present )
Cesc -- 8 ( misplaced a few passes but definitely going up the curve since his injury, nice to see him score again )
Hleb -- 7 ( quiet and effective game )
Diaby -- 7 ( I think he has improved, held the balls less and defended better )
Eduardo -- 7 ( perfect team player )
Adebayor -- 8 ( He's up the curve, I hope he gets African player of the year )

Overall, this was a magnificent performance as a unit.
 

nazo

Established Member
Almunia -- 6
Clichy -- 7
Senderous -- 7
Gallas -- 7
Sagna -- 7
Flamini -- 8.5
Cesc -- 7
Hleb -- 7
Diaby -- 7
Eduardo -- 7
Adebayor -- 7.5
 

RammiXP

Well-Known Member
Almunia -- 8- Not much to do but when called upon was there
Clichy -- 7 - Solid
Senderous -- 7- a couble of senderos moments but otherwise solid
Gallas -- 7- did not see much of him which i guess is good for a defender
Sagna -- 7- solid
Flamini -- 9 - Outstanding, best performance by him in an arsenal shirt to date i would say
Cesc -- 7.5 - great goal and as always is command but still not at his peak
Hleb -- 7 - good movement and interlink as you expect from hleb these days the most under rated player in the league.
Diaby -- 7.5- Much improved today however i still do not feel he is good enough
Eduardo -- 6.5 - Quite i thought today, could have done more to get involved
Adebayor -- 8- as always a pest and made newcastle panic on many occasions.

Nic- 7- the assit was great and i like him, i really think he is going to be big for us, when given the chance.
 

ZanYGooneR

Active Member
Almunia - (7) Didn't have much to do but i felt he was off his line very quickly when needed to be and always looks assured.

Clichy - (8) Once again faultless the kids jus immense, the best left-back in the world by far!!!!

Senderos - (7) Another good game in the absence of Toure, he's looking much more confident and his reading seems to be improving.

Gallas - (7) I didn't really notice him much but i suppose that's a good thing for a defender.

Sagna - (7) Another top performance, sometimes I forget he only joined us this season because he playes like he's been with us for years. Some excellent crossing.

Flamini - (9) MOTM Awesome performance, faultless, setup Ade, scored a cracker and covered every blade of grass.

Fabregas - (7) I thought Cesc was ok today at times he looked a little sluggish and uninterested, however I felt he actually improved once he moved out to the right and scored.

Hleb - (7) Overall I thought Hleb was ok today but once again I have to say Hleb should be starting on the left, he's so much better there. We saw this in the last 15mins when he moved to the left. He looks so much more comfortable there.

Diaby - (6.5) I thought he played well but never really did anything constructive. He won the ball well at times got out of tight spaces but he just looks a little slow at times, then again he is out of position.

Eduardo (6.5) Some nice link up play with Ade, but at times he does the wrong thing, like shooting when should of passed or passing when he should shoot some nice touches though.

Adebayor (7.5) Another good game for the big man, he's just looking so confident right now with some nifty footwork, excellent work-rate once again and good see another header. He gives us a dimension no-one else gives us.

Subs:

Bendnter (6) I thought he looked lively, superb control to setup Cesc.

Walcott - Not enough time to judge to be honest.


Overall good game excellent win well played lads :)
 

Christofaux

Active Member
Almunia - 7 Came out well when needed, Even if owen was Onside he would still beat him to the bal

Clichy - 7
Senderos - 7 shaky clearance but fantastic defence against a predominantly ground attack.
Gallas - 7
Sagna - 7 good coming forward, has such a good cross on him, at the start of the season he had no cross.
Flamini - 10 I honestly dont see one fault in his performance, crucial tackles, great linkup play, fantastic goal. Wahts the point in giving a 9 here?
Cesc - 7 Saint Nick is handing out gifts a month late.
Hleb - 7
Diaby - 7 Easily his best game so far, of which i have been thinking/saying for a while is definately being played into form.
Eduardo - 6 Had good movement but can't get the ball. Was defended well against.
Adebayor - 8 fantastic movement, great headed goal, should probably have had another but was still a good effort.

Nic - 7 Great control on the assist. could have taken the shot himself but unselfishly squared it up for Fabs.
 

qs

Established Member
Almunia -- 7
Clichy -- 8
Senderous -- 7
Gallas -- 7
Sagna -- 8
Flamini -- 9
Cesc -- 8
Hleb -- 8
Diaby -- 7
Eduardo -- 7
Adebayor -- 9
 

Invincible

Established Member
Almunia 7
Gallas 7
Senderos 6
Clichy 7
Sagna 6
Flamini 10 (Yes 10!)
Fabregas 7
Hleb 6
Diaby 6
Eduardo 6
Adebayor 8

Bendtner 7
Gilberto 6
Walcott N/A
 

gunnerGH

Established Member
qs said:
Almunia -- 7
Clichy -- 8
Senderous -- 7
Gallas -- 7
Sagna -- 8
Flamini -- 9
Cesc -- 8
Hleb -- 8
Diaby -- 7
Eduardo -- 7
Adebayor -- 9

Pretty much spot on id choose the same ratings. :)
 

arsmile

Established Member
al-8- quick off line, saved all the sots

sag-7
wil-7
send-7
clich-8

hleb-7.5
fab-7.5
flams-8.5
diably-7

eduardo-7
ade-8

bendtner-8
theo and gilb-7
 

Gooner_Stu

Established Member
Going on the ext highlights on SkySports & 5 Live radio

Almunia -- 7
Clichy -- 8 Everyday hes not in the French National team is a blessing to us, If hes not there by Euro '08 then Raymond Domenech should be hung for treason.
Senderous -- 7
Gallas -- 7
Sagna -- 7 Best buy of the season, looks like hes been with us for years.
Flamini -- 9 MotM, amaing game & goal.
Cesc -- 8
Hleb -- 7
Diaby -- 7 (Better the recent games on the left)
Eduardo -- 7
Adebayor -- 8.5
 

dutchMasta

Well-Known Member
Almunia - 6 (Don't remember him doing much, didn't need to, but had the offsides not been given, he would've made some great clearances out of the area)
Clichy - 8 (Some great tackles, and runs, almost some very good balls)
Senderos - 7.5 (Intercepted and cut out a lot, impressed)
Gallas - 7.5 (Great as well)
Sagna - 7.5 (Solid and some great crosses)
Flamini - 9 (Was everywhere, 1 goal + 1 assist, vital incterceptions
Cesc - 7.5 (Ok, but good goal, and ball to Flamini for the 1st)
Hleb - 7 (Decent, rough start)
Diaby - 7 (Better game, some nice long balls switching play)
Eduardo - 6.5 (Decent, some impressive moments)
Adebayor - 8 (Yet another goal, good movement, interplay, etc., on fire)

Bendtner - 7 (Some nice headers and unselfish for our 3rd)
Walcott - N/A (Not enough time)
Gilberto - N/A (Not enough time)
 

USArsenal

H.Y.I.C.
i am recording the replay of the game tonight... will give my ratings once I watch the whole match.. impossible to judge based on highlights and text commentary....
 

Clrnc

Established Member
Trusted ⭐

Player:Tomiyasu
Almunia 7
Sagna 7.5
Gallas 7
Senderos 7.5
Clichy 8
Hleb 7
Cesc 7.5
Flamini 10 - deserved it
Diaby 7.5 - improving, good to see
Ade 8
Eduardo 7.5

Bendtner 7
Gilberto 5.5
Walcott N/A
 

xcdude24

Established Member
aluminum- 7

Sagna- 7.5
Bill- 7
Phil- 7.5
Clichy- 8

Hleb- 7.5
Cesc- 7
Flamster- 9
Diaby- 7

Ade- 8
Eddy- 7

Nick- 7
Bert- 6.5
Theo- N/A
 

GoonerGurjit

Established Member
Almunia 6.5
Sagna 7
Gallas 7
Senderos 6.5
Clichy 7.5
Flamini 8
Fabregas 6
Diaby 6.5
Hleb 6
Eduardo 6
Adebayor 7

Gilberto 6
Bendtner 7
 

Biggus

Established Member
Almunia 7, Faultless.
Sagna 7,
Gallas 7
Senderos 7, Well done Phil.
Clichy 7,
Flamini 9, MOTM.
Fabregas 7,
Diaby 7,
Hleb 6
Eduardo 5, Disappointing.
Adebayor 8,

Gilberto 6,
Bendtner 6,

Really enjoyable to watch. Flamini's bossing of the game gave us a real menacing look, All our attacks were varied, left, right, long ball, short pass. Gone is the pointless endless short passing in area's that are harmless to the opposition.......Good stuff.
 

HollandGooner

Established Member

Country: Netherlands

Player:Ødegaard
Almunia nothing to do so no rating,
Sagna 7 very lively
Gallas 7 solid
Senderos 6.5 he has a good game.
Clichy 7.5 well, what a athetlete he is tremendous pace and defending quality,s will be a world beater
Flamini 8,5 he was everywhere he takes the role of Cesc and him both yesterday!
Fabregas 6,5 well his goal will give him some more confident i hope. we want the old cesc back, but he is still even he doenst play very good very important.
Diaby 6.5
Hleb 7 was lively but after the yellow he was playing more patiently
Eduardo 6
Adebayor 7

Gilberto 6
Bendtner 7
 

Gurgen

Established Member
Almunia 7
Sagna 7
Gallas 7
Senderos 7
Clichy 7
Hleb 7
Cesc 7
Flamini 9
Diaby 6
Eduardo 6
Adebayor 8

Bendtner 7
Gilberto 6
 

Zico

Established Member
Invincible said:
Almunia 7
Gallas 7
Senderos 6
Clichy 7
Sagna 6
Flamini 10 (Yes 10!)
Fabregas 7
Hleb 6
Diaby 6
Eduardo 6
Adebayor 8

Bendtner 7
Gilberto 6
Walcott N/A

Invincible, I would go with that exactly. Yes, a 10 is deserved because Flamini gave the best performance by an Arsenal player this year. Haven't seen anything like that since Henry took apart Liverpool.
 

gunnerGH

Established Member
quincy42 said:
Invincible, I would go with that exactly. Yes, a 10 is deserved because Flamini gave the best performance by an Arsenal player this year. Haven't seen anything like that since Henry took apart Liverpool.

Haha, bit different don't you think?
 

Latest posts+

Top Bottom