Country: Scotland
Usual format
1.
2
3
11
10
9
Few jars caused me to be late COYG
Podolski
Diaby
Arteta
9.Giroud
1.
2
3
11
10
9
Few jars caused me to be late COYG
Podolski
Diaby
Arteta
9.Giroud
-
! ! ! IMPORTANT MESSAGE ! ! !
Discussions about police investigations
In light of recent developments about a player from Premier League being arrested and until there is an official announcement, ALL users should refrain from discussing or speculating about situations around personal off-pitch matters related to any Arsenal player. This is to protect you and the forum.
Users who disregard this reminder will be issued warnings and their posts will get deleted from public.
Champions League – Montpellier vs Arsenal - Player Rankings
- Thread starter bingobob
- Start date
- Replies 25
- Views 3,202
Country: Scotland
Country: England
1.Podolski
2.Gervinho
3.Mannone
11. Giroud
10. Arteta
9. Vermaelen
2.Gervinho
3.Mannone
11. Giroud
10. Arteta
9. Vermaelen
Flow
Well-Known Member
1. Podolski
2. Gervinho
3. Arteta
9. Mertesacker
10. Giroud
11. Jenkinson
2. Gervinho
3. Arteta
9. Mertesacker
10. Giroud
11. Jenkinson
KyleHyde
Well-Known Member
Gervs
Poldi
Mannone
Giroud
Jenkinson
Santi
Poldi
Mannone
Giroud
Jenkinson
Santi
ferrarif50hunt
Established Member
1/ Arteta (6 tackles!!!! 95% passing)
2/ Gervinho
3/ Podolski
11/ Giroud
10/ Mertesacker
9/ Diaby
2/ Gervinho
3/ Podolski
11/ Giroud
10/ Mertesacker
9/ Diaby
FinnGooner
Established Member
1. Mannone (not that he had to make tons of game savers but the only player who didn't f**k up once)
2. Gervinho
3. Podolski
9. Gibbs
10. Diaby
11. Giroud (Still believe in his ability but it may take longer than we'd like, right now pretty useless I'm afraid)
2. Gervinho
3. Podolski
9. Gibbs
10. Diaby
11. Giroud (Still believe in his ability but it may take longer than we'd like, right now pretty useless I'm afraid)
jaguars4ever
Active Member
1 - Poldi
2 - Gervais
3 - Diaby
11 - Giroud
10 - Walcott
9 - Ramsey
--
Also, all you shameless 9-10-11'ers need to follow the format and get with the program. You know who you are.
2 - Gervais
3 - Diaby
11 - Giroud
10 - Walcott
9 - Ramsey
--
Also, all you shameless 9-10-11'ers need to follow the format and get with the program. You know who you are.
Wouterus
Well-Known Member
1. Don Vito
2. Podolski
3. Gervinho
11. Mertesacker
10. Diaby
9. Giroud
Imo a player must have played at least 30 minutes to be able to make a judgement. It is quite unfair and silly to put Ramsey and Walcott at the bottom three.
2. Podolski
3. Gervinho
11. Mertesacker
10. Diaby
9. Giroud
Imo a player must have played at least 30 minutes to be able to make a judgement. It is quite unfair and silly to put Ramsey and Walcott at the bottom three.
Mudi
Well-Known Member
jaguars4ever said:
Ramsey? Really?
I was happy when he came on. We finally had some grip back on the midfield.
Buhry
Established Member
Country: Norway
Why not make these topics actual player ratings? So much more interesting than just ranking the top 3 and bottom 3, which really says nothing about how the various players played.
Moderator Edit: Start your own ratings/discussions threads, then. This is bingobob's project.
Moderator Edit: Start your own ratings/discussions threads, then. This is bingobob's project.
Cudareli
Antonio Valencia stan
Buhry said:
Agreed completely.
Think this can be done in addition to the ratings if people really want to, but other then what i find it somewhat useless. Player ratings are a far better reflection.
In games that we dominate and outplay a team like Southampton, you are asking people to pick the 3 worse players on the pitch, despite there being next to nothing between all 11.
If you want to analyse it, you can do a top 3, but a bottom 3 is just crazy.
Moderator Edit: Again, start a traditional ratings thread yourself, which, incidentally, will also have a 'bottom three', ties notwithstanding.
G0D
Almighty
You must REALLY dislike Walcott to judge him as the second worst player on the pitch when he played 4 whole minutes.jaguars4ever said:
Anywho.
1. Podolski
2. Gervinho
3. Mannone (though this could really be almost anyone)
11. Giroud
10. Diaby
9. Cazorla
Cudareli
Antonio Valencia stan
G0D said:
Which sums up why this system is so missleading.
ArsenesNO1Fan
Established Member
Only managed to watch the highlights, was Giroud that bad? He assisted at least today
Gervinho has turned into an unplayable BEAST though
Gervinho has turned into an unplayable BEAST though
KyleHyde
Well-Known Member
ArsenesNO1Fan said:
That was the only notable thing he did. He tried a couple of times at the first half but they were mostly in vain, but the second half is where things just fell down. He was basically just a tall Chamakh(last season) there.
mo50
Established Member
1. Gervinho
2. Podolski
3. Gibbs
11. Giroud
10.
9.
9 and 10 is a toss up between several players. Too late in the day for my brain to remember the game so I'll add them tomorrow.
2. Podolski
3. Gibbs
11. Giroud
10.
9.
9 and 10 is a toss up between several players. Too late in the day for my brain to remember the game so I'll add them tomorrow.
RUS arsenal
Established Member
Wow, except for Poldi, Gervinho and Giroud these are all over the place. I haven't seen most of the 2nd half so I'll post my rankings when/if I watch the whole thing.
DontPushMe
Well-Known Member
1. Gervinho
2. Podolski
3. Gibbs
9. Mertesacker
10. Diaby
11. Giroud
Not including coquelin or walcott as they played 4 mins but coqs only contribution was getting blown by and nearly causing diaby to give up a penalty
2. Podolski
3. Gibbs
9. Mertesacker
10. Diaby
11. Giroud
Not including coquelin or walcott as they played 4 mins but coqs only contribution was getting blown by and nearly causing diaby to give up a penalty
