Just wondering about Spotlight:Gilberto

[kNiteMare]

Isnt the opinions in the post on the main site too one sided? I dont know if i remember correctly, but there must be still someone in there who were having a go at him. Just thinking that if it's spotlight, shouldnt the opinions be a bit more balanced to reflect real opinoin of him?

My memory could be wrong, but someone was definitly having a go at him i think.

 

[vin de guerre]

i wonder if that could have possibly been clock_end?
Well if you want a ballanced opinion "the end" is not where you want to search for it!

 

[Xanshin]

Mine got on there...so that's what matters

And the trouble is, too many people have a go at Gilberto, with no reason/knowledge...

So I think they did the right thing in only posting the positive things.

 

[Gunner4life09]

i can't remember what i said about Gilberto the last time there was a theard but i think he's a quality who isn't showing his true pontential. he's showing some now with the leeds thrashing and his sudden pace in the Birmingham game or was it the Pompey . . . sorry can't remember.

 

[RocktheCasbah]

It was Birmingham, he didn't play afgainst Pompey.

 

[Gunner4life09]

It was Birmingham, he didn't play afgainst Pompey.

oh ok thx, sorry about that i couldn't watch the game as it was on at 3:30 in the morning and SATs is next week.

 

[Taozhe]

Normally when u haf a player of the month.... u talk good things about him ... not the bad things... sheesh.

 

[kNiteMare]

but this is not player of the month. THis is spotlight, where i think the idea is analyse a player and allow us fans to give an opinion. I am sure not everyone on this forum likes him.

Dont say i am trying to create a fight or anything, and i do like Gilberto and supported him since the beginning, but my point is I think it should be a subjective reflection of fans' opinoin on the forum.

 

[Andrew]

I think the spotlight thing was to say good things about the players. Everyone has their opinions and no doubt they stated them elsewhere I just wished they kept to saying good things about the players or nothing at all in those threads.

 

[Jinn]

Ask bobbypires. He's in charge of picking the quotes.

If he wants to pick nice things to say, its his perogative.