Liege-Arsenal player ratings

[xcdude24]

Mannone- 6

Eboue- 4.5
Gallas-5
Vermaelen- 7
Clichy- 5. Played better in the second half though

Diaby-4. Good assist though and i'll imagine that'll be Wenger's rationale for starting him on saturday
Fabregas- 5. Not really a captain-esque performance
Song- 6

Rosicky- 7.5
Bendtner- 7.5
Eduardo- 6

 

[True Gooner]

Mannone- 6

Eboue- 4
Gallas-5
Vermaelen- 7
Clichy- 4


Fabregas- 5
Song- 4
Rosicky- 7.5

Diaby - 4 (3 without the assist)
Bendtner - 7.5
Eduardo - 4 (3 without the goal)

Subs:
Ramsey - 6
Sagna - N/A
Wilshere - N/A

 

[GaelForce22]

Bedtner, Rosicky, Vermaelen good.

The rest poor, Song, Cesc and Clichy in particular.

 

[Proof]

Mannone - 6

Eboue - 5
Gallas - 5
Vermaelen - 7
Clichy - 4.5

Diaby - 4
Fabregas - 4.5
Song - 6

Rosicky - 6
Bendtner - 6
Eduardo - 6

 

[lagos]

Everyone got an extra point because we won, so subtract 1 for my view on their actual performance on the day

Mannone- 6

Eboue- 6
Gallas-5
Vermaelen- 7
Clichy- 5.

Diaby-5.
Fabregas- 5.
Song- 6

Rosicky- 7
Bendtner- 6
Eduardo- 6

 

[Kraig]

Mannone - 4

Eboue - 4
Gallas - 5
Vermaelen - 7.5
Clichy - 4

Diaby - 4
Fabregas - 5
Song - 5

Rosicky - 7.5
Bendtner - 7
Eduardo - 5

Ramsey - 6

 

[arsmile]

Vito-6- not very busy, did everything more or less right- dodgy kicking- no fault for the goals
Eboue-6.5- thought he was alright, one vital clearance
Galas-5- I dotn think it was a penalty but he shouldn’t have done it- struggled a little after that
Vermaelen-8-fantastic
Clichy-5- primarily awful, but one fantastic challenge
Song-7-had 85 good minutes
Cesec-4- poor
Rosicky-7- mostly good
Eduardo-5- ridiculous mistake, nothing else, then a knee!
Diaby-5- difficult to rate, one good assist, sometimes really weak on the ball, often bad decision making
Bendtner-8- thought he was really good, good goal
Ramsey-6
Sagna-6
Wilshere-6

It is difficult to give one single rating, cos they all deserve 2s for the first half and hour- but a very very good second half performance, set up by bendtner’s goal

 

[giuliob]

5=average

Mannone- 5 Welcome to the big leagues
Eboue- 4
Gallas-5
Vermaelen- 7
Clichy- 4 Hasn't learned how to defend in their corner
Diaby-4 Assist was a nice piece of work...
Fabregas- 4 Show why you are called world class
Song- 5 Worked hard; did okay
Rosicky- 6 Oh Tommy, it's good to see you on the pitch...
Bendtner- 7 Lovely goal; thinks he can dribble around players like Henri
Eduardo- 5 The poacher's goal

Sagna 6
Ramsey 5
Wilshere 5

 

[James]

Mannone 6

Eboue 5
Gallas 6
Vermaelen 7
Clichy 5

Diaby 5
Fabregas 5
Song 6

Rosicky 7
Bendtner 7
Eduardo 5

 

[Captain]

all I know is that Rosicky and Nicky B were our best.

 

[General]

Mannone 7 - Thought he showed a lot of maturity today.

Eboue 5 - Poor end product as usual.

Gallas 6 - Got better as the game wore on.

Vermaelen 6 - Did well but poor composure in the dying minutes with some aimless hoofs

Clichy 4.5 - Too nervous and far too erratic in everything he did.

Diaby 6- He can make **** happen. Better defensive showing than against City.

Fabregas 5 - Average and lacked cutting edge.

Song 6.5 - Physically stood up to the task but has a habit of dwelling too long on the ball.

Rosicky 6.5 - Very busy but far too intricate.

Bendtner 6.5- Good movement and worked hard but was very selfish at times.

Eduardo 5.5 - Struggled to get into the game and did better when he moved in centrally.

 

[truth_hurts]

Mannone- 6 - decent enough.

Eboue- 6 - decent game i felt in both ends of the pitch.
Gallas-5.5 - below par today and very silly for the penalty.
Vermaelen- 7 - despite our defensive error TV was strong tonight.
Clichy- 4 - 6 is average, 5 is below average, clichy is lucky to get a 4. awful positioning and Dalmat tore him up.

Diaby -5.5 the good/evil, jekhll/hyde diaby show again. Great work for the assist.
Fabregas- 5. sloppy and uninspiring
Song- 6 - not a particularly good performance tonight. He grew into the game though

Rosicky- 7.5 - pretty awesome creatively and defensively. That ball to bendtner in the 2nd half summed him up.

Bendtner- 7 - very good, well taken goal, held up the play well and looked like a top level striker.

Eduardo- 6 - poor performance but did what he was there to do.

Subs:-

Ramsey - 6.5 - thought he looked very lively.

Sagna - 6 - didn't have much to do.

Wilshere - 6 - battled hard and a few neat touches.

 

[qs]

Mannone - 6 did nothing wrong but little was asked of him.

Eboue - 4 terrible in attack, lost the ball for the pen, made up a little with some decent defending in the 2nd half
Gallas - 2 ridiculous penalty to give away 2 minutes after conceding, pretty poor for the whole first half. Quiet 2nd.
Vermaelen - 7 did pretty well in defence, covered Gallas and Clichys bad games
Clichy - 2 terrible all round. 2nd truly awful game in a row. Sort it out and make way for Gibbs.

Diaby - 5 **** game overall but an important game changing moment rescued him a bit
Fabregas - 4 started out ok but got worse as the game went on. The team carried him tonight
Song - 4 slow, terrible passing, missing for most of the first half defensively. Like Clichy its 2 bad games in a row. Sadly we don't even have a 2nd choice DM to drop him for.

Rosicky - 7 worked hard and was bright throughout
Bendtner - 8 once he was moved into the middle he workrate and intelligent movement changed our attacking play for the better. Topped it off with a well deserved goal. More of this please.
Eduardo - 4 his ratings rescued by his goal. Apart from his huge **** up early on he was piss poor throughout the first half and wasn't much better in the second.

 

[ricky1985]

Bedtner, Rosicky, Vermaelen good.

The rest poor, Song, Cesc and Clichy in particular.

In complete agreement. I'll add that I think Bendtner and Vermaelen were very good.

 

[gunnerGH]

Mannone 6
Clichy 4
Eboue 5
TV 6
Gallas 5
Rosicky 7 MOM
Diabolical 5
Song 5
Fabregas 5
Bendy 6
Edu 5

Ramsey solid
Wilshere not long
Sagna kk

 

[banduan]

gawd i miss rosicky

 

[Unforgiven]

Mannone- 6

Eboue- 6
Gallas-5
Vermaelen- 7
Clichy- 3


Fabregas- 5
Song- 4
Rosicky- 7.5

Diaby - 3.5
Bendtner - 7
Eduardo - 5

 

[Double_H]

i really dont know what happend to clichy post back injury
but i agree with Unforgiven but with diaby and gallas 3

 

[GunneDown]

Mannone- 6

Eboue- 3
Gallas-5
Vermaelen- 7
Clichy- 3


Fabregas- 3
Song- 3
Rosicky- 6

Diaby - 3
Bendtner - 6
Eduardo - 4

 

[fabo]

How are people giving Song a better rating than Fabregas. Both were incredibly poor if anything but the difference was Song was giving the ball away/conceding free-kicks in our half. Woeful display and he hasn't performed since Celtic away.

Good:
Bendtner, Rosicky and Vermaelen. Maybe Gallas sneaks in as he made some crucial headers second half.

The rest were garbage.