Man City vs Arsenal player rankings

[morpho]

Mannone - 6
Jenkinson - 7
Mertesacker - 7
Koschielny - 8
Gibbs - 7

Arteta - 6
Diaby - 6
Cazorla - 7

Podolski - 5
Gervinho - 6
Ramsey - 7

Walcott - 5
Giroud - 5

=============


1. Koschielny
2. Jenkinson
3. Cazorla

 

[Tangy99]

1. Jenkinson
2. Ramsey
3. Mertesacker

9. Podolski
10. Diaby
11. Gervinho

If Walcott had been on longer, his performance would have put him in the bottom 3.

Wasn't much between Per and Kos for me either.

Also, it was really tough to choose the bottom 3, Gervinho was the only player who frustrated me today though even he showed some promising stuff.

 

[ferrarif50hunt]

1/ Jenkinson
2/ Koscielny
3/ Cazorla

11/ Podolski
10/ Mannone
9/ Gervinho

 

[RUS arsenal]

1. Jenkinson
2. Mert
3. Cazorla


Some players had poor moments or stretches due to being rusty or tired or I'm not going to give out any bad marks. No one really stunk up the place to deserve it.

 

[Yousif Arsenal]

The Best:
1- Per
2- Jenko
3- Kosh

The Worst

1- Vito
2- Gervinho

 

[Wouterus]

1. Cazorla
2. Jenkinson
3. Ramsey

11. Gervinho
10. Mannone
9. Podolski

 

[Yaya]

1.Mertesacker
2.Ramsey
3.Jenkinson

11.Gervinho
10.Mannone
9.Podolski

 

[krengon]

1. Jenkinson
2. Ramsey
3. Mertesacker

 

[Rain Dance]

1. Jenks
2. Per
3. Ramsey

---------
11. Gerv

 

[bingobob]

Player rankings? What is this crappy system? I miss the old 'rate the player'.

Go create your own thread then instead of making me waste time trying to figure out your voting order (your vote is void btw)

---

Im just finishing tallying off the results for the City game and I'll post an update to where the players stand hopefully some surprising results.

 

[iced22]

1. Mertesacker
2. Jenkinson
3. Ramsey

9. Podolski
10. Diaby
11. Mannone

 

[TheArsenalis]

1 merte
2 ramsey
3 jenks

8 manone
9 poldi
10 gerboue

 

[USArsenal]

1. Jenkinson
2. Ramsey
3. Koscielny

9. Podolski
10. Gervinho
11. Mannone

 

[evoh_1]

1.) Mertesacker - never tackled because he read the ball all day long
2.) Koscielny - tackled and cleared the ball brilliantly (+ the goal)
3.) Jenkinson - up and down and made strong defenders look weak

11.) Gervinho - the misses and heavy touches, wastes all the good he does
10.) Podolski - never in the game hardly any quality when on the ball
9.) Diaby - weak display in getting the ball back but some nice runs out shone by arteta, ramsey and cazorla.

Mentions for Ramsey here he was fantastic with the ball and did what we want from diaby perfect way to showcase his ability in the middle of the park as a ball winner.

 

[redwhiteAustrian]

1. Jenks
2. Ramsey
3. Cazorla

9. Gerv
10. Poldi
11. Mannone