RVP had two good seasons for us, 2010-11, he was our top goal scorer with 18 in the PL helping us to 4th place, and in 2011-12 he carried us to 3rd, with 30 goals in 38 appearances, and then signed for Man U scoring 26 goals in 38 appearances and carrying a rickety team to the title. During those 3 yrs he was untouchable and the best striker in the world. Auba hasnt been able to carry a team over a season yet. we came 6th and 8th in his time here. This season will settle the debate, and theres a fair chance he will prove himself a better striker than RVP with a settled team and manager. As it stands, RVP shades it.