<

Rate the Transfer Window 19/20 edition

Discussion in 'Arsenal Talk' started by Toast, Sep 2, 2019.

?

How would you rate our transfer business on a scale from 1-10?

  1. 10

    6.7%
  2. 9

    29.2%
  3. 8

    50.6%
  4. 7

    11.2%
  5. 6

    1.1%
  6. 5 or lower

    1.1%
  1. drippin

    drippin Well-Known Member

    Fraser ordered blocking our youth's path. :drool: ;) :lol:
     
  2. North5

    North5 Here since 2009. Unlike Cornavirus.

    8/10 for most reasons already stated.


    For the first time in a long time I feel we are finally moving full steam in the right direction.

    Hopefully unai sorts himself out
     
  3. drippin

    drippin Well-Known Member

    Burnout & meltdown combination too probable for betting companies to even put up the bet.

    Eventhough do we even have 3 defensive midfielders? Chambers doesn't count as he is saved as CB backup I think, we cannot risk Mustafi being at bench if someone is injured. Bad energy even sitting there.
     
    Trilly likes this.
  4. American_Gooner

    American_Gooner Not actually American. Unless Di Marzio says so. Moderator

    Don't think he'll last until Halloween, nevermind Christmas.
     
    GeorgiaGunner and Trilly like this.
  5. GeorgiaGunner

    GeorgiaGunner Closet United Fan

    Oof, but hey, @Rex Banner keep your head up -- even Ali took a punch once in a while.

    ;)
     
    Rex Banter likes this.
  6. It is good for an Arsenal window but i`ll still give it a 5... Where is the defenders that we should have bought?
    We had aweful defending last year and still bought only 1 potenially good defender in Tierney
    Luis is not that good he is a cheap way to fill the gaping holes in the back only, same as Sokratis was

    For sales it is good that we finally have started to get rid of some players that isnt good enough, but we have plenty of them left with high wages to be a bump in the road...

    Hoping for January but it might be to late already then..
     
  7. lamby22

    lamby22 It's Not Lupus

    8/10 for me. Got some good additions in and rid of a lot of dross. Would have kept Nacho until January as we don't know if Tierney is going to come back and not break down.

    At the start of the window we were linked with Fraser and Carrasco and it was all doom and gloom with us trying to justify to ourselves how they could do a job. To end up with Pepe and Ceballos is :drool:

    Mustafi though.... I can't blame anyone but him for the fact that he's still here. He just won't flush.
     
  8. James Bond

    James Bond Moderation Consultant

    I think some people need a refresher...we lost steam in the league and failed to reach top 4 then we put in a limp performance and lost to an already CL qualified Chelsea. Stories 40m budget getting churned out each and every day and people wondered what the hell we’d do without Ramsey...

    The club then signed a attacker who get you up out of your seat who was pegged to join on of the big boys but then Arsenal ‘knocked’ and smashed their transfer record/paid a fee within the top 5 all time by a PL club for a player, signed a top end LB, as well as a top CB prospect and then went on and loaned a baller from Real ****ing Madrid. On top of that the club/Raul and co then went and moved on some cast offs in Elneny, Jenkinson and Mhki.

    Take a step back and remember the context and this window is/was nothing short of a 11/10 as NOBODY at supporter level saw this coming. Seriously think back and remember all the work you thought we had to do with the squad at FT in Baku, but with no CL draw or money and then really think about what was done in one window....madness.
     
    ThlRama, razörist and GeorgiaGunner like this.
  9. drippin

    drippin Well-Known Member

    This is what I meant with when thinking about what to compare to. For me giving 10 would need Upamecano transfer or similar CB this window, or Mustafi out. They clearly tried though.

    But it seems for some people to give even 9 it would need all these transfers in & out, plus Zaha & Upamecano, plus Mustafi out. Even without UCL.

    That is very unrealistic.
     
  10. Swallow

    Swallow Well-Known Member

    For me, this is a 9/10 window mainly because I did not anticipate the level of business we did. There are improvements still to be made but we have to acknowledge that it would have been crazy to overhaul the entire playing body in one window.

    For those complaining about the defense, I think that those in charge acted taking into consideration a few factors. Firstly, we have promising players recovering from injury. Both Holding (for left CD) and Mavropanos (for right CD) have the potential to do well. Hence this season will be used to evaluate their progress. If they do well we will have four centre-backs in Saliba, Holding, Mavropanos and Chambers who will be a great mix for the foreseeable future. Luiz and Papa will allow us to integrate them slowly. We then will have to focus on improving both the full-back positions. Mustafi will definitely go.

    In midfield, we are covered if we could make Ceballos permanent. The one improvement I personally would make, apart from shifting Xhaka, would be to replace Toreira with Ibrahim Sangare from Toulouse. That would significantly increase the height of our defense. For the strikers, a very good left winger would have lifted our front line to elite level, but again there are youngsters we have to take into consideration for that position. By the end of the season, we will have a fairer idea of the improvements needed.
     
    drippin likes this.
  11. Mrs Bergkamp

    Mrs Bergkamp Well-Known Member

    Realistically, it's a 7 for me. We did well with the ins but we should have done better on shifting some especially Mustafi. Not getting a starting defender also feels like a trick missed especially with the loss of Kos and Monreal. I'm happier with the players we got this summer compared to last year where only Guendouzi and Torreira gave me some hope. This window certainly wasn't underwhelming.
     
  12. Tir Na Nog

    Tir Na Nog In Big Trouble If He Speaks

    Went with 8 but selling Iwobi and not replacing him could put it down to a 7. It'd never be a 10 because as good as Luiz is he's not exactly the world class CB signing we should be making.
     
    Iceman10 likes this.
  13. Iceman10

    Iceman10 Well-Known Member

    The issue of "replacing" Iwobi is complex. We did bring in Pepe and Martinelli. For LW, Auba, Martinelli, and Reiss can play there. It's not necessarily that we didn't replace Iwobi, imo, it is more that we took a gamble, probably as per Raul/Edu, one we will have to see if it pays off.
     
    drippin likes this.
  14. Hleb's Sirush

    Hleb's Sirush Well-Known Member

    If I rate this window by looking just at what we needed, the stature of our club, the appeal of the PL then I would give it 8/10. Very good window.

    If I rate it by taking in consideration the specific hurdles for this window, that we missed CL for 3 seasons, needed to fill what looked like a million holes in the squad, fierce competition for any decent player, our budget etc. Then it is a 9.5/10. An almost perfect window when those challenges are considered.
     
    drippin likes this.
  15. Hleb's Sirush

    Hleb's Sirush Well-Known Member

    Sorry mate, but I hope if you do get to watch a game that it turns out to be the worst game ever. 2 shots in total for both teams, with only 1 on target and the game ends 0-0.

    I can half picture you jumping down and start shouting at Emery "you ****ing coward, why did you need to play 10 defensive players? I came all the way from the Netherlands to watch this s hit on a stick"

    You would love to see that :lol:
     
  16. Jae

    Jae Well-Known Member

    Just need a world class DM now and we're good to go for the next few years.
     
  17. Makingtrax

    Makingtrax Arséne Wenger once said "I will miss you"

    5/10
    For years our defence has been shambles. We needed:
    Class DM
    Class CB
    Back up for RB
    Long term replacement at LB

    We’ve got just one of those, Luiz is better than Mustafi but not what we needed. Ceballos was a short term replacement for Ramsey and Pepe is a luxury addition to the attack.
     
  18. Manberg

    Manberg Predator

    People forgot we signed Saliba.
     
    Sanchez11 likes this.
  19. Garrincha

    Garrincha Wilf Zaha Aficionado

    Blows that not really played since we signed him.
     
  20. Tir Na Nog

    Tir Na Nog In Big Trouble If He Speaks

    I can actually see your thinking, once again we're basically gambling on our starting back four to stay fit the entire season, meanwhile our 2 starting FB's are injured already and we're forced to see Kolasinac and a midfielder at full-back. While I personally would have Holding ahead of Sokratis but that's debatable. If we're relying on Kolasinac/AMN for long periods this season it'll cost us points. While none of our CB's are exactly Adams-Bould either. Luiz has his moments, Sokratis is brainless and there's still question marks over Holding and Chambers.

    It honestly seems to be like we're gambling yet again, what we did plenty of times under the last regime and I don't think it should be overlooked this time either especially if things go tits up. It's alright spending all that money on Pepe but last season it was our defence that let us down and it'll probably be the same this season. In the NLD 3 members of our defensive setup, our DM, CB and GK all made mistakes leading to the two Sp**s goals. Vs Liverpool we lost Matip on a set-piece so he could a free header while Luiz pulled Salah's shirt with quite lazy defending and he was embarrassed be Salah for the 3rd. Just 4 games into the season and already we see our defence is quite unreliable. I can only hope we're gonna be scoring a lot of goals this campaign.
     
    Makingtrax likes this.

Share This Page

Watch Arsenal Live Streams With StreamFootball.tv

Do Not Sell My Personal Information