Matchday Ratings, Arsenal/Man U

[Macho]

Are you intentionally trying to be thick? He mean't to hit his shot so badly that it went to Gallas? Some assist.

Still an assist.

Hey maybe Rooney's goal wasn't a goal as he didn't kick it properly :roll:

 

[IBL]

Almunia 5 - he keeps doing it; comes off his line when there are enough defenders around him leaving the goal wide open. I fear its the end for him because he doesnt seem to learn.

Sagna 6 - positionalyd in dissarray at times, did well for Cesc's goal
Touré 7.5 - good game if not commanding
Gallas 7.5 - top display from Gallas, I'm starting to warm to him as captain and as a CB
Clichy 6 - better attacking than defending

Eboue 6 - did ok, defended well from the front
Cesc 8 - where would we be without him this season
Flamini 7 - solid
Rosicky 6 - offered very little
Hleb 7 - looked very lively and fiesty, should have got a penalty
Adebayor - 7 worked hard with end product

Walcott 6
Eduardo 5
Gilberto 5

I agree with the rest but what exactly was Ade's end product which deserved a 7 apart from breaking down play.

oops, that should have read "worked hard with little end product".

He played a part in our first goal, good run and made the keeper work which lead to our goal

 

[MDGoonah41]

Ill tabulate tomorrow. Get'em in.

 

[Lord Dula]

Almunia 6
Sagna 6.5
Touré 7
Gallas 8
Clichy 7
Eboue 6.5
Cesc 7.5
Flamini 6.5
Rosicky 6
Hleb 8
Adebayor 6

Walcott 5.5
Eduardo 5.5
Gilberto 5

 

[Biggus]

Almunia 6

Good to see you retain your sense of humour my liege.

 

[Alfonso]

so Biggus, does Gallas get 4 or 5?

 

[MDGoonah41]

so Biggus, does Gallas get 4 or 5?

My exact thought when I started the thread.

"well, other than the last gasp equalizer, he was crap. "

 

[Jameel46]

Almunia - 5.5
Sagna - 6.5
Touré - 7.5
Gallas - 8
Clichy - 7
Eboue - 7
Fabregas - 7.5
Flamini - 6
Rosicky - 6
Hleb - 7.5
Adebayor - 6

Walcott - 6
Eduardo - 6
Gilberto - 6

 

[Biggus]

so Biggus, does Gallas get 4 or 5?

My exact thought when I started the thread.

"well, other than the last gasp equalizer, he was crap. "

Meh wiseguys eh yuk yuk yuk. I gave my score for Gallas, and yes he was pretty average until he wiped the smile off Fungi's face....thats worth a bit. :wink:

 

[Clrnc]

Are you intentionally trying to be thick? He mean't to hit his shot so badly that it went to Gallas? Some assist.

Still an assist.

Hey maybe Rooney's goal wasn't a goal as he didn't kick it properly :roll:

HUH?

didn't it deflect off a manure defender before going to gallas

 

[MDGoonah41]

You guys really just refuse to list the players in the order I give, don't you

Click here for a larger image

Part 2

Click here for a larger image

Part 3

And here's the overall form chart

Click here for a larger image

 

[Clrnc]

so the highest ever ratings is still by ade 9.1

walcott have the honours of being the best ever sub, 7.4

mdg41, do you collect other competitions tally?

 

[MDGoonah41]

Not enough people rate the CC matches, and I have the Sevilla and Bucharest ratings, I don't remember if enough people even bothered with Slavia ratings. If they did, I can tabulate it.

 

[giuliob]

@MD Still think it's a good idea to have an Arsenal thread called comprehensive match ratings or something like that where you can dump all of the ratings.....It's really up to you.....If you don't mind the work of having to put the ratings in two spots - the game day ratings thread and a comprehensive ratings thead.....

 

[Clrnc]

i think its better we have all the matches of arsenal instead of only epl

 

[MDGoonah41]

i think its better we have all the matches of arsenal instead of only epl

I agree, but a sample of 7 or 8 people is very limited and is somewhat insignificant. If more people rated the Champions League and Carling Cup matches, it would be better for the study. As I said, I have the Sevilla and Bucharest ratings, and if someone created a Slavia ratings thread, I can get those, but I thought I remembered it only being a few people, if I'm remembering one at all.