dutchMasta
Well-Known Member
Yeah, deserved sending off I think. Definitely unsportsman-like behaviour.
-
! ! ! IMPORTANT MESSAGE ! ! !
Discussions about police investigations
In light of recent developments about a player from Premier League being arrested and until there is an official announcement, ALL users should refrain from discussing or speculating about situations around personal off-pitch matters related to any Arsenal player. This is to protect you and the forum.
Users who disregard this reminder will be issued warnings and their posts will get deleted from public.
Arsenal vs Derby - Match Review and Player Ratings
- Thread starter asajoseph
- Start date
- Replies 60
- Views 6,284
giuliob
Well-Known Member
Seems harsh, sending him off considering all the stuff that is written on this forum.....Maybe a PM, explaining criteria for sending off.....
AliBabaBrewer
Well-Known Member
Fabianski - 5
Clichy - 7
Song - 5
Gallas - 6
Toure - 6
Walcott - 7
Fabregas - 7
Denilson - 7
Eboue - 5
Bendtner - 8
Van Persie - 6
Adebayor - 8
Gilberto - 6
Djourou - N/A or 5
And in the topic of this thread, I actually think Senderos and Toure both have good passes about them. I have noticed on occasion that Senderos has actually been able to pick out some very good passes.
And Toure's seems to have had a long and heavy dip in form since ANC, but by no means a poor player. Next season, with a rest, he'll be back at his best. And everyone seems to be knocking him, but he's playing out of position.
It's not like Eboue, who apparently (according to Wenger), who should be good in his new position, and has the attributes to be, but just fails miserably. This is a bloke playing completely out of position. It's like people coating off Flamini for playing left back. He shouldn't be there, so cut him some slack.
Clichy - 7
Song - 5
Gallas - 6
Toure - 6
Walcott - 7
Fabregas - 7
Denilson - 7
Eboue - 5
Bendtner - 8
Van Persie - 6
Adebayor - 8
Gilberto - 6
Djourou - N/A or 5
And in the topic of this thread, I actually think Senderos and Toure both have good passes about them. I have noticed on occasion that Senderos has actually been able to pick out some very good passes.
And Toure's seems to have had a long and heavy dip in form since ANC, but by no means a poor player. Next season, with a rest, he'll be back at his best. And everyone seems to be knocking him, but he's playing out of position.
It's not like Eboue, who apparently (according to Wenger), who should be good in his new position, and has the attributes to be, but just fails miserably. This is a bloke playing completely out of position. It's like people coating off Flamini for playing left back. He shouldn't be there, so cut him some slack.
Biggus
Established Member
arsmile said:
Here it comes again Luka.....
Its true, Jens was much better when he wasn't going bald.....though that doesn't explain the American baldies- Friedel, Keller & Hahnemann who are quite useful......maybe 'cos they get lots of practice during games. Almunia's blond perm has given you the illusion that he is a much better keeper than he is too......
:wink:
arsmile
Established Member
Biggus said:
maybe you have got something there...i did use to prefer jens before this season.......god, I choose my gks based on their hair!!
i dont.. al's great !!!!
hoyden
Active Member
If you want to know whether he is as tall as the other two, why not just look at the squad picture:
http://www.arsenal.com/images/wallpaper ... 8_1024.jpg
http://www.arsenal.com/images/wallpaper ... 8_1024.jpg
arsmile
Established Member
hoyden said:
yeah but their posture is an insermountable anomoly!!
nazo
Established Member
Gurgen said:
Kind of agree with that.
banduan
Established Member
B-b-b-but Asa ya know if you don't diss Senderos you obviously don't know anything about football! M I RITE???
Jeez. First the "Hleb is never good enough but oh Eboue is so underrated" gig then that malarkey.
Jeez. First the "Hleb is never good enough but oh Eboue is so underrated" gig then that malarkey.
AnthonyG
Arse Emeritus
I've said it few time this season, when Phil pushes up to the half his vertical pass is good and incisive. When he has to pass horizontal in his own half he's OK unless he has to lift the ball, then it can get away from hit a bit.
Kolo is, by and large a hoofer, though he has the ability to play more 1-2's than Phil due to his pace and this might colour some people's overall perception. Gallas is OK, but he'll hit an opposition man more than Sendy will.
Lately all of our defenders have been, to steal the phrase, 89 minute defenders, so that concerns me more than their respective, ahem, passing grades.
For the match - I'll give them a collective 100 and they can fight over it.
Kolo is, by and large a hoofer, though he has the ability to play more 1-2's than Phil due to his pace and this might colour some people's overall perception. Gallas is OK, but he'll hit an opposition man more than Sendy will.
Lately all of our defenders have been, to steal the phrase, 89 minute defenders, so that concerns me more than their respective, ahem, passing grades.
For the match - I'll give them a collective 100 and they can fight over it.
banduan
Established Member
Yup. Forget the 1-mistake a match Senderos. What about 1-mistake a match Gallas and Toure?
Country: England
Thought that ban was a bit harsh to be honest. I have read and been called much worse in this forum.
As for Senderos, Toure and Gallas- yep they are all 1 mistake a match defenders.
At least Gallas and Toure have the bottle to come back from it though, or at least not let it affect their whole match. Or need to take sick leave...
As for Senderos, Toure and Gallas- yep they are all 1 mistake a match defenders.
At least Gallas and Toure have the bottle to come back from it though, or at least not let it affect their whole match. Or need to take sick leave...
Biggus
Established Member
hoyden said:
Fabianski's probably standing on a chair.
mccroix
Well-Known Member
So many high ratings for Nick?
Do you really think he was that good?
He was quite good and I like him but I don't think he was better than a 7
Do you really think he was that good?
He was quite good and I like him but I don't think he was better than a 7
Country: England
Funny enough, I was thinking the same thing.makaveli tha don said:
I just assumed people may saw somethig I didn't.
A few gave him the same ratings as Ade.
nazo
Established Member
Ah come on. He literally ripped them apart. Doesn't matter if it's Derby but he literally ripped them apart. He actually surprised me with the quality and range of passing he showed.
stiiphunn
Established Member
Tbh he's always been very good at link up play. He really is a smart player and you could see that from day one. If you take into account his age, it's quite brilliant really.bluenaz said:
arsmile
Established Member
cloista said:
which i think has surprised wenger who saw them as playin the same role, to the extent to which i swear he once said they wouldnt play together
Yep I remember that too.
To be honest, Bendtner was the second striker all through his early career, in the reserves especially, Lupoli got all the credit for being a goalmachine, but Bendtner put a huge amount of them on a plate for him. Bendtner + RvP is arguably our weakest partnership now that RvP has become more team focused and intent on playing as a pure second striker, as it means we play without an out n out striker like when Eduardo or Ade or Theo play up top.
To be honest, Bendtner was the second striker all through his early career, in the reserves especially, Lupoli got all the credit for being a goalmachine, but Bendtner put a huge amount of them on a plate for him. Bendtner + RvP is arguably our weakest partnership now that RvP has become more team focused and intent on playing as a pure second striker, as it means we play without an out n out striker like when Eduardo or Ade or Theo play up top.
