Aston Villa - Arsenal, player ratings

[kel varnsen]

almunia - 6
sagna - 4
clichy - 5
vermaelen - 5
gallas - 6
denilson - 4
cesc - 5
ramsey - 4
arshavin - 6
eduardo - 5
rosicky - 5

bendtner - 7
campbell - 7

 

[Arai]

almunia - 6
sagna - 4
clichy - 5
vermaelen - 5
gallas - 6
denilson - 4
cesc - 5
ramsey - 4
arshavin - 6
eduardo - 5
rosicky - 5

bendtner - 7
campbell - 7

Campbell - 7.5... :bounce

 

[True Gooner]

almunia - 6
sagna - 4
clichy - 5
vermaelen - 5
gallas - 6
denilson - 4
cesc - 5
ramsey - 4
arshavin - 6
eduardo - 5
rosicky - 5

bendtner - 7
campbell - 7

I'd switch Sagna's ratings with Clichy but the rest is spot on.

 

[Segway]

Almunia 6

Sagna 6
Gallas 6.5
Vermaelen 5
Clichy 4

Denilson 4
Cesc 6.5
Ramsey 5

Rosicky 6
Eduardo 4
Arshavin 6.5


Campbell 7.5
Bendtner 7

 

[dreamLord]

Almunia - 6

Clichy - 5
Gallas - 6.5
Campbell - 7.5
Sagna - 5.5

Denilson - 480+320-650+426/942*0
Fabregas - 6.5
Ramsey - 6

Rosicky - 5
Eduardo - 5
Arshavin - 7

Bendtner - N/A, but very promising. Needs to get the rust off his boots and score a goal against one of the big teams to get his confidence back.
Nasri - N/A

 

[Lord Dula]

Only ones who can be proud are Sol, Cesc, Rosicky, Arshavin and Bendy

 

[progman07]

Arshavin was very good, I thought. We were unlucky not to win. At least a 7 to him and Cesc.

People are driven by the result too much, when deciding on ratings. One lucky goal in the end, and Arshavin-Cesc are hailed for their performance, while if we have lost it after a 90th min counter-attack, they'd get even lower ratings.

 

[Clrnc]

almunia - 6
sagna - 6
clichy - 4
vermaelen - 5
gallas - 7
denilson - 3
cesc - 7
ramsey - 5
arshavin - 7
eduardo - 5
rosicky - 6

bendtner - 6
campbell - 6.5

 

[russkiegooner]

almunia - 7
sagna - 5
clichy - 5
vermaelen - 6
gallas - 7
denilson - 4
cesc - 6
ramsey - 5
arshavin - 7
eduardo - 5
rosicky - 5

bendtner - 5
campbell - 8 MOTM

 

[Captain]

Only ones who can be proud are Sol, Cesc, Rosicky, Arshavin and Bendy

Gallas was our best player by a country mile.

 

[OohtobeaGoonerGal]

People are driven by the result too much, when deciding on ratings. One lucky goal in the end, and Arshavin-Cesc are hailed for their performance, while if we have lost it after a 90th min counter-attack, they'd get even lower ratings.

Yeah I agree with this, so I usually take these with a pinch of salt.

 

[MAK 14]

Almunia 6

Sagna 6
Gallas 6.5
Vermaelen 5.5
Clichy 4.5

Denilson 4
Cesc 6.5
Ramsey 5

Rosicky 6
Eduardo 5
Arshavin 6.5

Campbell 7.5
Bendtner 7

 

[1970*Gooner]

almunia - 6
sagna - 4
clichy - 5
vermaelen - 5
gallas - 8
denilson - 2
cesc - 7
ramsey - 4
arshavin - 6
eduardo - 4
rosicky - 5

bendtner - 5
campbell - 5

 

[thegame24]

Fab, sol, gallas, arshavin and nasri only ones that i can praise.

 

[russkiegooner]

Arshavin was very good, I thought. We were unlucky not to win. At least a 7 to him and Cesc.

People are driven by the result too much, when deciding on ratings. One lucky goal in the end, and Arshavin-Cesc are hailed for their performance, while if we have lost it after a 90th min counter-attack, they'd get even lower ratings.

That's a good comment, Prog. To be completely fair, Arshavin was very average in the first half, and Cesc wasn't as good in the second. But both looked pretty good overall. Should have Cesc or Arshavin scored after their excellent runs (in the first and second halves respectively), they would have been acclaimed as heros. But they didn't and now it's knee-jerking time.

One day our recent luck should have changed. I did today.

 

[longrufus]

Only ones who can be proud are Sol, Cesc, Rosicky, Arshavin and Bendy

Gallas was our best player by a country mile.

Completely agree Capi, and Rosicky was very poor in my eyes.

 

[krengon]

Gallas was excellent for us. Campbell and Bendtner played well too, which is a positive. Arshavin and Cesc had their moments, rest was average/poor.

still really disappointed with this result, feels like a loss right now.

 

[dutchMasta]

Almunia - 7 (Fine, kicking had no purpose until Bendtner came on)
Sagna - 5.5 (Ok)
Clichy - 5 (Struggled)
Vermaelen - 6 (Fine until injury)
Gallas - 8 (Immense at the back)
Denilson - 4
Fabregas - 6 (Flashes of brilliance)
Ramsey - 5 (Didn't step up)
Arshavin - 7 (Some great moments, teammates need to get him more involved)
Eduardo - 5 (Weak up front alone)
Rosicky - 5 (Missed a great chance)

Bendtner - 7 (Won headers)
Campbell - 7.5 (Experienced play)
Nasri - (Didn't notice him)

 

[Lord Dula]

Only ones who can be proud are Sol, Cesc, Rosicky, Arshavin and Bendy

Gallas was our best player by a country mile.

Sorry, yeah missed him out. He always plays well.

 

[ibby]

Almunia - 7, no mistakes however, someone needs to teach him to ONLY come out for the ball when he is sure he can catch it.

Sagna - 6
Clichy - 5 He looks a little bit rusty and still had a 'Clichy moment' when he turn his back like against Birmingham two years back
Vermaelen - 6
Gallas - 8 - Outstanding.

Denilson - 4 *sigh* Probably his worst game this season.
Fabregas - 7 Good game.
Ramsey - 6 His passing was a bit off today but tracked back well.

Arshavin - 7 Nice run of form recently which coincides with him moving back to the left.
Eduardo - 5 This is NOT his formation.
Rosicky - 6

Bendtner - 7 Had a good game when he came on, won a few headers and held the ball up well.
Campbell - 8 Great to have Sol back. :worthy