Ashybashy86
Well-Known Member
Lol *Crickets*. Tbf to him, Bellerin doesn't create any space for him. Gets crowded out.
Taking Luke Shaw as an example of a good defensive full back is hilarious...
I cant stress this enough one good game against liverpool does not mean hes amazing and one good piece of skill per match does not mean you ignore the rest of the performances.
Hes completely inconsistent except for most of his contributions come against the weaker teams. He got 6 starts in a row over Christmas iirc and got one goal against utd and that was about it. Some days hes good most days hes bad.
Lets take a look a this ability to glide past defenders against brighton... couldnt fkin do it could he? Was given the ball with one man to beat about 4-5 times. Another 4-5 times with 1 defender helping cover the first, any winger who is known for dribbling will beat his man 1 on 1 nearly every time and quite a few times even when it is 2 on 1
In saying all that I think Arteta is setting up to get the absoloute best out of him...
Because I can't quote your post Hleb, I'm gonna try and limit my response because this is getting out of hand and I think no matter how many bad games he has you'll always make excuses like the team wasn't setup right or somebody else wasn't playing well so how can we expect him to, or the the windspeed was 15 knots south west when he needs an gentle easterly breeze. I've seen the same excuses for limited players like Lacazette and Özil.
I genuinely think most of you're points are rubbish and again just excuses we should ignore or gloss over a lot of bad performances for the very rare good one.
Just to clarify some things I think he is a decent dribbler, he just blows very hot and cold and from what I've seen in an Arsenal jersey its cold for the most part. I wouldn't chuck him in the bin yet as he is one of the least concerns I have with the squad, but he has been poor, very poor.
I hope you were watching tonight and looking for reasons to come on here and say oh Pepe was great tonight look at a,b and c but again he was poor, he didn't do it against Brighton can't do it against Southampton, who is next? I'm hoping hes tarts doing something soon because we badly need more inspiration than our 18 year old academy graduate. And yes Shaw is a poor defensive full back.
Also saying Arteta basically ignores an entire wing and uses it as a decoy is ridiculous.
OK, in what way can he do anything if Bellerin and Mustafi miss 95% of the forward passes?Bellerin and Cebellos didn't help him out but conversely he didn't help them out either.
My criticism of him (and I rate him), is that on a day like yesterday he needs to find a way to get involved, in spite of what's happening in the game.
Bellerin is a massive problem for Pepe and the whole team.OK, in what way can he do anything if Bellerin and Mustafi miss 95% of the forward passes?
Are you saying that he should win the ball in his own half, run with it to the box and assist for the goal? That's the only solution I see when you play next to bums like our defenders. There's no way this guy can play to his full potential within this team, and it's not his fault. Messi would struggle in this team
Bellerin missed passes yesterday but I also don't think he found much space.OK, in what way can he do anything if Bellerin and Mustafi miss 95% of the forward passes?
Are you saying that he should win the ball in his own half, run with it to the box and assist for the goal? That's the only solution I see when you play next to bums like our defenders. There's no way this guy can play to his full potential within this team, and it's not his fault. Messi would struggle in this team
Think we've watched a different game, we didn't press as a team at all, and instead, we've decided to soak the pressure and wait for their mistakes. If we need a right forward who will be more of a defender, that we should search for another option or a different manager because Pepe is not about that.Bellerin missed passes yesterday but I also don't think he found much space.
And yes, what I'm referring to is him pressing better and winning some of his own football. He didn't help Bellerin much on the defensive side.
My point being, when it's not going his way in an attacking sense (through some elements out of his control), I'd like to see him working harder in defence. Trying to create a bit of chaos. Win some ball and help on transition.
Bellerin is not the player who enjoys being on the ball, he likes to run behind the defence and sprint back when needed, that's all he is.Bellerin is a massive problem for Pepe and the whole team.
He cannot pass or progress play in any way. He's so "stiff" on the ball and has lost most of his pace/energy.
Upgrading on Bellerin is almost as crucial as revamping the entire midfield.
I guess that's the gap between us and Liverpool then.Think we've watched a different game, we didn't press as a team at all, and instead, we've decided to soak the pressure and wait for their mistakes. If we need a right forward who will be more of a defender, that we should search for another option or a different manager because Pepe is not about that.
If you spend 70m on a technically superior wide forward who is one of the best dribblers atm, you don't expect him to work harder in defence, you set the team to focus their passing to him so he can make a difference in attack.
Even if we go your way, I've always felt that Pepe is actually working hard with the team instead of being a lazy technical player. He does get back and is always within a defensive formation with his team.
or the the windspeed was 15 knots south west when he needs an gentle easterly breeze.
That's a complete bs, they work exactly the same. The difference is, when Liverpool wins the ball their defenders don't panic with it. Liverpool also likes to press teams more than we do, which can give a false idea that their forwards are working more. Our manager decided to sit back instead of pressing teams, which makes it harder for our forwards to win the ball back and it falls down to defenders to do it, but as I say, when they finally win it, they panic and quickly give it back.I guess that's the gap between us and Liverpool then.
They've got fowards like Mane and Salah worth in excess of £70m who work much more effectively in defence than Pepe.
I agree, but South Americans mostly have tenacious attitude. I've ragged on Pepe in the past, but really do believe he needs a RB who will make overlapping runs to open up some space.Work rate, off the ball defensive work, press and win some football and take it in transition. Sanchez did it well early in his Arsenal career. He should know a lot of ball is going to go down the left hand side, it's our better wing.
He was anonymous yesterday. That said, he still very nearly contributed with an assist.
Whilst we were fortunate with our first goal, we were quite wasteful otherwise.
Bellerin and Cebellos didn't help him out but conversely he didn't help them out either.
My criticism of him (and I rate him), is that on a day like yesterday he needs to find a way to get involved, in spite of what's happening in the game.
Work rate, off the ball defensive work, press and win some football and take it in transition. Sanchez did it well early in his Arsenal career. He should know a lot of ball is going to go down the left hand side, it's our better wing.
Conversely, they attacked our right hand side a lot yesterday, win it and go. I think if he improves that, it will add consistency to his game by closing the gap between his good and bad performances.
Is there a reason why you feel he works better on the counter? I've had a feeling about this guy that he is deadly when he is closer to the goal, so maybe if we could assemble a team that controls the ball 60% of the time would take the best out of him. I just don't see him as a guy who will run up and down all day. The only question is, would it be faster to set the team for the counter attacking football or would it be faster to make some transfers that would give us more control over the game.The only thing we can say with certainty is that if we can start getting more early goals like the great Arsenal teams of the past, it will give him a lot more countering opportunities. There's a reason he's been impressive in most of our big games that we haven't been stuffed in.
That's true, I don't agree with the guy at all but at least he is backing up his opinion with somethingThis is the kind of constructive criticism worrh debating, rather than some people criticising him for stuff that are demonstrably untrue.
I actually agree with you. He can work harder off the ball.