Player:Tomiyasu
Almunia 7
Sagna 7
Gallas 8
Vermaelen 8.5
Clichy 6.5
Song 8
Cesc 9
Denilson 7
Arshavin 7
Bendtner 6
RVP 5
Diaby 7
Sagna 7
Gallas 8
Vermaelen 8.5
Clichy 6.5
Song 8
Cesc 9
Denilson 7
Arshavin 7
Bendtner 6
RVP 5
Diaby 7
-
! ! ! IMPORTANT MESSAGE ! ! !
Discussions about police investigations
In light of recent developments about a player from Premier League being arrested and until there is an official announcement, ALL users should refrain from discussing or speculating about situations around personal off-pitch matters related to any Arsenal player. This is to protect you and the forum.
Users who disregard this reminder will be issued warnings and their posts will get deleted from public.
Celtic vs Arsenal Match Ratings
- Thread starter Clrnc
- Start date
- Replies 68
- Views 8,071
Player:Tomiyasu
ibby
Established Member
Cesc was better than Song, Vermaelen and Gallas?
go49oner
Established Member
Almunia 6
Sagna 7
Gallas 8
Vermaelen 8
Clichy 7
Song 9 MOTM
Cesc 9
Denilson 7
Arshavin 6.5
Bendtner 6.5
RVP 5
Diaby 6
Sagna 7
Gallas 8
Vermaelen 8
Clichy 7
Song 9 MOTM
Cesc 9
Denilson 7
Arshavin 6.5
Bendtner 6.5
RVP 5
Diaby 6
Unforgiven
Established Member
Almunia 7
Sagna 7
Gallas 9
Vermaelen 9
Clichy 6.5
Song 8.5
Cesc 8.5
Denilson 7.5
Arshavin 7
Bendtner 6
RVP 5
diaby 7
Sagna 7
Gallas 9
Vermaelen 9
Clichy 6.5
Song 8.5
Cesc 8.5
Denilson 7.5
Arshavin 7
Bendtner 6
RVP 5
diaby 7
Feet
Active Member
RvP deserves more than a 5. Not much more, but he chased down the ball all day even if he didn't really get a clear sight of goal.
GaelForce22
Established Member
Almunia 7 - Did he have a save to make?
Sagna 7
Gallas 9
Vermaelen 9
Clichy 7
Song 9
Denilson 6
Fabregas 8
Bendtner 6
Van Persie 6
Arshavin 7
Diaby 6
Sagna 7
Gallas 9
Vermaelen 9
Clichy 7
Song 9
Denilson 6
Fabregas 8
Bendtner 6
Van Persie 6
Arshavin 7
Diaby 6
nazo
Established Member
Almunia 6
Sagna 7
Gallas 9
Vermaelen 8.5
Clichy 7
Song 8
Cesc 7
Denilson 7
Arshavin 6
Bendtner 6
RVP 6
Diaby 6
Sagna 7
Gallas 9
Vermaelen 8.5
Clichy 7
Song 8
Cesc 7
Denilson 7
Arshavin 6
Bendtner 6
RVP 6
Diaby 6
Feet
Active Member
Gallas, Vermaelen, Song and Cesc were stand out excellent, but there wasn't a bad performance out there from our side, everyone did their share of the hard work required to compete away from home in Europe.
In fact I'm just surprised we didn't see Ramsey or Eboue really so we could rest some of the first eleven, so the only person I can really negatively critique is Wenger, but only by a whisker.
In fact I'm just surprised we didn't see Ramsey or Eboue really so we could rest some of the first eleven, so the only person I can really negatively critique is Wenger, but only by a whisker.
A_Gooner_Matata
Established Member
Count me out of the ratings and recriminations. It's just a brilliant result at a tricky venue.
otfgoon
Established Member
Almunia - 7
Sagna - 7
Gallas - 9
Vermaelen - 9
Clichy - 6
Song - 8
Cesc - 7 (tempted to give an 8 for the amount of work he put in)
Denilson - 6
Arshavin - 5
Robin - 5
Bendtner - 5
Sagna - 7
Gallas - 9
Vermaelen - 9
Clichy - 6
Song - 8
Cesc - 7 (tempted to give an 8 for the amount of work he put in)
Denilson - 6
Arshavin - 5
Robin - 5
Bendtner - 5
M+D
Established Member
Almunia - 6
Sagna - 6
Gallas - 8
Vermaelen - 8
Clichy - 6
Fabregas - 7.5
Song - 8.5
Denilson - 7
Bendtner - 7
Van Persie - 6
Arshavin - 6
Sagna - 6
Gallas - 8
Vermaelen - 8
Clichy - 6
Fabregas - 7.5
Song - 8.5
Denilson - 7
Bendtner - 7
Van Persie - 6
Arshavin - 6
giuliob
Well-Known Member
5=average
Almunia 6 Didn't really have much to do...
Sagna 6.5 Solid game...
Gallas 8
Vermaelen 8.5 He looks like the real deal; well done...
Clichy 6 Still looks like he's working out the kinks; is he a step slower?
Song 8.5 Consistent; passed well; good cover...
Cesc 6.5 Celtic boxed him pretty well the 1st half...
Denilson 6.5 Decent game...
Arshavin 6
Bendtner 6 Got off to a slow start; seemed to move better in the 2nd half..
RVP 5 "Almost" will be his middle name soon; didn't seem comfortable out there.....
Diaby 6.5
Away kit looked good...professional and class.......
Almunia 6 Didn't really have much to do...
Sagna 6.5 Solid game...
Gallas 8
Vermaelen 8.5 He looks like the real deal; well done...
Clichy 6 Still looks like he's working out the kinks; is he a step slower?
Song 8.5 Consistent; passed well; good cover...
Cesc 6.5 Celtic boxed him pretty well the 1st half...
Denilson 6.5 Decent game...
Arshavin 6
Bendtner 6 Got off to a slow start; seemed to move better in the 2nd half..
RVP 5 "Almost" will be his middle name soon; didn't seem comfortable out there.....
Diaby 6.5
Away kit looked good...professional and class.......
Klaus Daimler
Established Member
Almunia: 6
Sagna: 7
Gallas: 8
Vermaelen: 9 and MOTM
Clichy: 7
Song: 8
Fabregas: 7
Denilson: 6
Arshavin: 6
Bendtner: 6
van Persie: 4
It's understandable that Wenger didn't wanted to risk Eduardo against those thugs, but this game illustrated the need of options up front. Bendtner and van Persie are not, have not been and will never be a good combination. Too static in the decisive moments, not clinical enough and drops too deep. Of the two Bendtner had a better game for the second time in a row (although his performance was subpar in the second half). I wouldn't start with Robin up front in the next game.
Great win otherwise, I thought. Impressive by all the hard work that Arshavin and Denilson did in both ends of the field. Celtic tried to kick us off the field but Song and Vermaelen stood up magnificently. The latter in particular perhaps. I'm quickly falling in love with Vermaelen. He's a ****ing terminator. Born without mercy.
Sagna: 7
Gallas: 8
Vermaelen: 9 and MOTM
Clichy: 7
Song: 8
Fabregas: 7
Denilson: 6
Arshavin: 6
Bendtner: 6
van Persie: 4
It's understandable that Wenger didn't wanted to risk Eduardo against those thugs, but this game illustrated the need of options up front. Bendtner and van Persie are not, have not been and will never be a good combination. Too static in the decisive moments, not clinical enough and drops too deep. Of the two Bendtner had a better game for the second time in a row (although his performance was subpar in the second half). I wouldn't start with Robin up front in the next game.
Great win otherwise, I thought. Impressive by all the hard work that Arshavin and Denilson did in both ends of the field. Celtic tried to kick us off the field but Song and Vermaelen stood up magnificently. The latter in particular perhaps. I'm quickly falling in love with Vermaelen. He's a ****ing terminator. Born without mercy.
arsmile
Established Member
al-7- diddnt have to do anything
sagna-7- good
gallas-8- good
vermealen-9- already in love a little bit
clichy-7- good
song-9- fantastic
denilson-7- some good stuff
cesc-8- instrumental
bendtner-6- did alright
arshavin-5.5- quite quiet
vanpersie-6- yep
diaby-7-if i rewrite him as a winger as opposed to a CM in my brain then he's fine- weak on the ball though
attacking wise we were not fantastic, but we kept the ball and were very solid in defence- more solid than we've been for a long time- thanks in no small part to song and vermealen.
sagna-7- good
gallas-8- good
vermealen-9- already in love a little bit
clichy-7- good
song-9- fantastic
denilson-7- some good stuff
cesc-8- instrumental
bendtner-6- did alright
arshavin-5.5- quite quiet
vanpersie-6- yep
diaby-7-if i rewrite him as a winger as opposed to a CM in my brain then he's fine- weak on the ball though
attacking wise we were not fantastic, but we kept the ball and were very solid in defence- more solid than we've been for a long time- thanks in no small part to song and vermealen.
MAK 14
Established Member
Almunia 7 - Was decent, don't remember him having that much to do.
Sagna 7.5 - Solid defending, pretty good in attack.
Gallas 8.5 - Fantastic defensive performance from Gallas, don't think he did anything wrong.
Vermaelen 8.5 - Same as Gallas, played great.
Clichy 7.5 - Good in attack, good in defense.
Song 9 - My man of the match. Another solid performance from Song.
Cesc 8.5 - Great work rate from Cesc, great performance too.
Denilson 7 - Played well.
Arshavin 7 - Even though he didn't score or assist, a good performance from him.
Bendtner 6.5 - Didn't do that much.
RVP 7 - I thought Van Persie did well.
Diaby 7 - Good run from him to get the second goal.
Sagna 7.5 - Solid defending, pretty good in attack.
Gallas 8.5 - Fantastic defensive performance from Gallas, don't think he did anything wrong.
Vermaelen 8.5 - Same as Gallas, played great.
Clichy 7.5 - Good in attack, good in defense.
Song 9 - My man of the match. Another solid performance from Song.
Cesc 8.5 - Great work rate from Cesc, great performance too.
Denilson 7 - Played well.
Arshavin 7 - Even though he didn't score or assist, a good performance from him.
Bendtner 6.5 - Didn't do that much.
RVP 7 - I thought Van Persie did well.
Diaby 7 - Good run from him to get the second goal.
ricky1985
Established Member
Almunia - 7. Not a lot to do, but was generally calm. His mindless distribution is absolutely infuriating though. Manuel should watch the Champions league final to see Valdes' great distribution under pressure.
Sagna - 6. Decent defensively, but had more sloppy moments than I'm used to seeing from him. One who has not quite clicked into gear yet.
Gallas - 9. Awesome. The reason Celtic didn't threaten is not because they were poor, it's because we defended brilliantly, and Gallas was a massive, huge part of that.
Vermaelen - 9. Superb, as good as Gallas, and better with the ball at his feet. Wenger is clearly a genius - what a signing! MOTM
Clichy - 7. Similar to Sagna - a few sloppy moments, but generally pretty good.
Song - 9. Two sloppy passes in the whole match. Incredible defending.
Fabregas - 7. I thought his incisive passing was slightly off all night. Like the fullbacks not quite slipped into the groove yet.
Denilson - 7. Some very impressive defending, but still sells himself in the tackle too often. Passing was weak at times.
Bendtner - 7. Some good link-up play and worked like a Trojan, but I felt, woeful in the final third.
Van Persie - 5. A few neat touches apart, I really felt he hindered us hugely tonight. Again worked very hard like everyone else.
Arshavin - 6. He needs better movement in the final third from his team mates and he'll become twenty times more dangerous. Hasn't hit full stride yet - more to come, much more!
Subs
Diaby - 7. Immediate effect, quiet thereafter.
Sagna - 6. Decent defensively, but had more sloppy moments than I'm used to seeing from him. One who has not quite clicked into gear yet.
Gallas - 9. Awesome. The reason Celtic didn't threaten is not because they were poor, it's because we defended brilliantly, and Gallas was a massive, huge part of that.
Vermaelen - 9. Superb, as good as Gallas, and better with the ball at his feet. Wenger is clearly a genius - what a signing! MOTM
Clichy - 7. Similar to Sagna - a few sloppy moments, but generally pretty good.
Song - 9. Two sloppy passes in the whole match. Incredible defending.
Fabregas - 7. I thought his incisive passing was slightly off all night. Like the fullbacks not quite slipped into the groove yet.
Denilson - 7. Some very impressive defending, but still sells himself in the tackle too often. Passing was weak at times.
Bendtner - 7. Some good link-up play and worked like a Trojan, but I felt, woeful in the final third.
Van Persie - 5. A few neat touches apart, I really felt he hindered us hugely tonight. Again worked very hard like everyone else.
Arshavin - 6. He needs better movement in the final third from his team mates and he'll become twenty times more dangerous. Hasn't hit full stride yet - more to come, much more!
Subs
Diaby - 7. Immediate effect, quiet thereafter.
Ginger_Reyes
Well-Known Member
Almunia: 6
Sagna: 8
Gallas: 8.5
Vermaelen: 9 Star PLayer
Clichy: 8
Song: 8.5
Fabregas: 7
Denilson: 4
Arshavin: 4
Bendtner: 6
van Persie: 4
Conclusion - Solid defence won us the game.
Sagna: 8
Gallas: 8.5
Vermaelen: 9 Star PLayer
Clichy: 8
Song: 8.5
Fabregas: 7
Denilson: 4
Arshavin: 4
Bendtner: 6
van Persie: 4
Conclusion - Solid defence won us the game.
- Thread starter
- #18
Player:Tomiyasu
Actually, he worked really really hard and was the main maestro of the whole team. I think he does deserve MOTM. all 4 was very very good though, and its nice to think those 4 have been consistently the best 4 in our 2 matchesibby said:
Raider
Established Member
Almunia 7
Sagna 7
Gallas 8
Vermaelen 8.5
Clichy 7
Song 8
Cesc 9
Denilson 6
Arshavin 7
Bendtner 5
RVP 5
Diaby 6
Robin and Nicklas just didn't get involved often enough. I can't believe how easy it is to dispossess robin whilst hes running at you. If there isn't an option either side of him, he shouldn't charge at the centre backs, it never comes off.
Sagna 7
Gallas 8
Vermaelen 8.5
Clichy 7
Song 8
Cesc 9
Denilson 6
Arshavin 7
Bendtner 5
RVP 5
Diaby 6
Robin and Nicklas just didn't get involved often enough. I can't believe how easy it is to dispossess robin whilst hes running at you. If there isn't an option either side of him, he shouldn't charge at the centre backs, it never comes off.
GoonerGurjit
Established Member
Almunia 6.5
Sagna 6.5
Gallas 8
Vermaelen 8.5
Clichy 7
Song 7
Denilson 6.5
Cesc 8
Arshavin 6
van Persie 6
Bendtner 6
Diaby 6
Sagna 6.5
Gallas 8
Vermaelen 8.5
Clichy 7
Song 7
Denilson 6.5
Cesc 8
Arshavin 6
van Persie 6
Bendtner 6
Diaby 6
